Analyze the case and opinion in the case of Riser v. QEP Energy, 777 F.3d 1191 (10th Cir. 2015) located in your textbook on pp. 451–454.Write a case study review of Judge Kelly’s opinion that answers the questions below. Support your review with analysis and evidence from the unit reading and outside sources.
- What are the legal issues presented in this case? Did the plaintiff establish a valid prima facie case of pay discrimination? Was there a basis for equal work? On what factors did the appeals court base its decision?
- Why is the other-than-sex factor that is presented by the employer insufficient to avoid a trial?
- What should the employer have done differently?
1
Your paper should include the
page number in the upper
right hand portion of every
page. This can be easily
achieved by going to Insert, Page Number, Top of Page,
and then selecting Plain
Number 3.
Animals as Equals in Science Fiction
Student Name
Columbia Southern University
Course Name
Instructor Name
Date
SAMPLE CASE STUDY
This case study is modelled after some of the most common case study assignments here at CSU.
Keep in mind that while some case study assignments will look like this, not all of them will.
In those circumstances, pay particular attention to the questions that your assignment is asking you
to answer or the issues it wants you to address: These will become your level headings. This is the
assignment that this sample paper is responding to:
Use the resource below:
Clements, J. (2015). How science fiction helps us reimagine our moral relations with animals.
Journal of Animal Ethics, 5(2) 181.
Then, write a case study that answers the following questions:
-What types of characters are defined as “animal” in literature?
-What real-world societal problems do such characters address?
APA 7th edition allows for a variety of different font choices for papers. Options include
Times New Roman (size 12), Calibri (size 11), Arial (size 11), Lucida Sans Unicode (size
10), and Georgia (size 11). This example paper is written in Times New Roman, size 12.
The same font and font size should be used throughout the entire paper.
2
Animals as Equals in Science Fiction
In her article “How Science Fiction Helps Us Reimagine Our Moral Relations with
Animals,” Jennifer Clements (2015) details several science fiction write rs who bring animals and
animalistic characters to the forefront of their works. While it is an oft-ignored genre, science
fiction tends to be filled with satires and metaphors that act as calls to action for the more
attentive reader. Of these metaphors, one of the most popular is the animalistic character. The
trope of the animal appears in such classics as Frankenstein, The Island of Doctor Moreau, and
Planet of the Apes (Clements, 2015). These novels all utilize their respective animal characters to
cast a new light on some aspect of humanity. Science fiction very rarely focuses on true animals.
More often, these animals are some sort of hybrid between the natural creature and man, giving
them the higher thinking necessary to comment upon a multitude of societal issues, especially
those of discrimination and segregation.
The Animal as a Character
One of the most legendary stories not only of the genre, but of literature as a whole, is
Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein: Or the Modern Prometheus. While many of the adaptations of
Frankenstein have badly skewed the original store, the central theme of the creature as an
innocent and largely peaceful being has, for the most part, endured. This is true for the creature’s
many counterparts in the genre; they are feared, physically abused, or shunned for either their
appearance or origins, and yet, they are kind, thoughtful, and intelligent. Essentially, the
animalistic character is meant to represent the best of what humanity could be. This is
particularly ironic since, in an overwhelming majority of such tales, humans created these
creatures through their own scientific prowess (Clements, 2015). These origin stories cause a
dilemma for readers: Siding with the animal character feels like a betrayal to mankind, but
The thesis acknowledges both
of the issues prompted in the
assignment, and provides brief
answers to them.
Notice that both of the body paragraphs’ level headings
respond to questions from the prompt. Refer back to the
assignment:
What type of creatures are referred to as “animal” in
literature?
Since this passage answers that question, it receives a
heading. These headings can either be a reworded version
of your assignment’s original question, like this one, or
indicate your response to the question or issue.
When paraphrasing a key point in more than one sentence
within a paragraph, cite the source in the first sentence in which it is relevant and do not repeat the citation within
that paragraph as long as the source remains clear and unchanged.
The full title of
the paper is
repeated here,
bold and
centered.
3
challenges the reader to consider the viewpoints of those who are fundamentally different from
themselves.
The Animal as a Representative of Societal Problems
In Frankenstein, the creature acts as an example of “the moral wrongs that newly
expanding scientific frontiers made possible” (Clements, 2015, para. 2); while this topic remains
especially relevant with the advent of artificial intelligence on the horizon, it is not necessarily at
the forefront of human thought in the twenty-first century. For much of the lesser known writer
Cordwainer Smith’s body of work, however, the issues at hand are much more similar to those of
modern America. Smith centers many of his short stories on the conflicts between the
Underpeople (an animal-derived human) and the True Men, who, true to genre stereotypes,
created the Underpeople in their own image. The conflicts between the Underpeople and the
True Men are blatant analogies for racism and religious persecution, and are especially effective
in their execution. Smith’s stories (and those of similar writers) encourage
“continual… negotiation (not denial) of difference” (Clements, 2015, para.9).
Conclusion
Animal characters serve to represent not what humanity is, but what it has the potential to
become. The origin of these characters is typically man, representing the fact that hate and evil
are uniquely human attributes. These problems, originating with man, must end with man to
create a more enlightened and caring being. The animal is used as a representative of these
problems because of their relative goodness compared to humans; they have no wars and no
hatred with which they are born. The lessons illustrated by these skilled authors, centering upon
these idealistic beings, are critically important in learning to overcome such major issues as
racism and homophobia, uniquely caused and perpetuated by humanity alone.
This level heading answers this question:
What real-world societal problems do such characters address?
Conclusions are critical in all academic
papers. This is where you will tie
together all of your thoughts and main
points made about your subheadings.
4
References
Clements, J. (2015). How science fiction helps us reimagine our moral relations with animals.
Journal of Animal Ethics, 5(2) 181.
The word “References” should be
centered at the top of the page in bold font.
If you have any generalized questions
about your references page, refer to
the APA Citation Guide.
http://www.columbiasouthern.edu/downloads/pdf/success/Citation-Guide